Why We Love Watching People Fail
Cringe culture, schadenfreude, public humiliation — and what the internet’s obsession with other people’s downfalls reveals about us
Have you ever noticed how quickly people gather when somebody falls?
A celebrity marriage collapses.
An influencer gets exposed.
Someone gets something spectacularly wrong in public.
Within minutes there are comments.
Reaction videos.
Screenshots.
Memes.
People saying:
I knew something was off.
And sometimes — if we are willing to admit it — there is another feeling underneath our curiosity.
A tiny flicker of satisfaction.
Not necessarily because we want someone else to suffer.
Sometimes it is because, for one moment, the person who looked more successful, beautiful, loved or certain than us suddenly looks human again.
This is the strange psychology behind cringe culture, celebrity downfalls, internet pile-ons and schadenfreude.
And perhaps the most interesting part is not what it says about the person everyone is watching.
It is what it reveals about the people watching them.
What Is Schadenfreude?
Schadenfreude is the pleasure or satisfaction someone experiences at another person's misfortune.
That sounds cruel.
But the emotional reality can be more subtle.
Sometimes what we experience is not exactly pleasure.
It is relief.
Imagine someone whose life appears to contain everything you want.
The relationship.
The career.
The money.
The confidence.
The body.
The beautiful home.
The perfect family.
You are comparing the messy interior of your own life with the polished exterior of theirs.
Then something goes wrong.
And for one brief moment, something inside you relaxes.
Oh.
Their life isn't perfect either.
Their fall has not improved your circumstances.
But it has changed the comparison.
And suddenly your own imperfect life does not feel quite so inadequate.
Why Celebrity Breakups Fascinate Us
Celebrity relationships make this particularly visible.
We watch photographs.
Interviews.
Weddings.
Children.
Anniversary posts.
Holidays.
Beautiful homes.
We receive fragments of someone else's relationship and unconsciously construct the rest.
Then the couple separates.
Suddenly everyone becomes an expert.
“I always knew.”
“They never looked happy.”
“It was obviously performative.”
But why do we need to prove that the relationship was never really as good as it appeared?
Sometimes it is because we were not only observing them.
We were measuring ourselves against them.
Their relationship became a symbol of something.
Love works.
Soulmates exist.
You can lose someone and find them again.
You can finally have the perfect ending.
When the fantasy breaks, the pedestal breaks too.
And strangely, that can create relief.
Maybe nobody has the perfect marriage.
Maybe nobody has everything figured out.
Maybe my own imperfect relationship or imperfect life is not evidence that I failed.
Why Cringe Makes Us Physically Uncomfortable
Then there is cringe culture.
Cringe is a strange emotion.
You watch someone do something with absolute confidence while everyone around them seems to be experiencing it completely differently.
You cover your face.
You want them to stop.
You almost feel the embarrassment in your own body.
But you keep watching.
Why?
Because cringe contains one of our deepest social fears:
What if I am the last person to know?
What if everybody can see something about me that I cannot see?
What if I think my relationship is wonderful and everyone else knows it isn't?
What if I think I am talented but everybody else thinks I am embarrassing?
What if I finally become fully visible and discover that the version of myself I believed in is
not the version everyone else sees?
This is one reason Raygun became such an enormous cultural moment.
People were not only watching a performance.
They were watching a nightmare many people quietly carry:
What if I believe in myself completely — and the world laughs?
The Internet Did Not Invent The Spectator
It is tempting to blame all of this on social media.
But human beings have been turning other people into spectacle for a very long time.
Reality television did it.
Talent shows did it.
Tabloids did it.
Public exhibitions did it long before television existed.
People have always been fascinated by the unusual, the shocking, the socially inappropriate and the person who gets something wrong in front of everybody.
The internet did something different.
It industrialised spectatorship.
We no longer need to buy a ticket.
The spectacle arrives in our hands.
And now we can participate.
We can comment.
Share.
Remix.
React.
Meme.
Freeze someone's worst moment and send it around the world.
Watching became participation.
How An Internet Pile-On Begins
One person criticises someone.
Then ten.
Then a thousand.
Eventually people who had never heard of the person two days earlier are confidently declaring:
She's a fraud.
He's a narcissist.
She's delusional.
He's evil.
She's embarrassing.
And there is an important social question here:
Would every person have said the same thing if nobody else had gone first?
Groups give us permission.
Once the crowd decides someone deserves ridicule, joining the ridicule becomes socially safe.
You are no longer the cruel person.
You are simply agreeing with everyone else.
Very quickly, the person stops being a complicated human being.
They become a role.
The cheater.
The scammer.
The failed influencer.
The narcissist.
The embarrassing one.
The villain.
And once somebody becomes a character, it becomes easier to stop imagining that they still contain a whole human life outside the story we have created about them.
What Black Mirror Understood About Social Media
This is why Black Mirror: Nosedive feels increasingly uncomfortable.
In the episode, people constantly rate one another.
Their score determines:
Where they can live.
Who respects them.
What opportunities they receive.
How other people treat them.
At first it feels dystopian.
Then remove the number floating above everyone's head.
What remains?
Followers.
Likes.
Views.
Comments.
Screenshots.
Trending topics.
Reaction videos.
The mechanism already exists.
Thousands of people collectively deciding:
We like you.
We dislike you.
You're aspirational.
You're embarrassing.
You're relevant.
You're over.
Black Mirror simply made the invisible score visible.
The Internet's Version Of You Can Become Bigger Than You
Another Black Mirror episode, Joan Is Awful, takes this idea even further.
Joan's life becomes entertainment.
Other people consume a version of her that she no longer completely controls.
This happens constantly online.
A person has an awkward moment.
A bad relationship.
A controversial interview.
A failed performance.
One clip becomes the story.
Then the story becomes the identity.
Eventually millions of people feel as though they “know” someone they have never met.
The internet's version of the person can become larger than the actual person.
And that is one reason humiliation travels so quickly.
Why Humiliation Spreads Faster Than Context
Humiliation is efficient.
You can understand it in seconds.
Someone thought something would work.
It didn't.
Someone was rejected.
Someone misunderstood the room.
Someone failed.
Someone confidently did something that everybody else found embarrassing.
You do not need twenty minutes of context.
You understand the social meaning almost instantly.
And humiliation invites participation.
We do not simply watch.
We imitate.
We meme.
We react.
We send it to friends.
Every repetition creates another version of the original moment.
Eventually the person at the centre can lose ownership of what happened to them.
Their mistake becomes collective entertainment.
Why We Love Watching A Pedestal Collapse
There is another familiar internet pattern.
Someone appears.
We love them.
Then they become successful.
We admire them.
Then they become extremely successful.
Suddenly they are everywhere.
And something changes.
“They're annoying.”
“They're overrated.”
“Something about them bothers me.”
Then something goes wrong.
And the reaction is immediate:
I knew it.
Why?
Sometimes a person's visibility touches something unresolved in us.
Beauty.
Money.
Love.
Status.
Talent.
Confidence.
Success.
They represent something we feel excluded from.
And bringing them down psychologically brings them closer to our level.
This does not mean criticism is always jealousy.
People genuinely do things deserving criticism.
Accountability matters.
But there are two different questions worth asking:
What did this person actually do?
And:
Why is my emotional reaction to them this intense?
Sometimes the second answer tells us much more about ourselves.
Why Someone Else's Failure Can Make Us Feel Safer
Imagine your own life feels uncertain.
Your relationship is struggling.
Your career has changed.
Something you believed would work has failed.
Then somebody publicly makes an enormous mistake.
Suddenly there is a person everyone can point towards.
They failed.
They made the terrible decision.
They should have known better.
And for a moment, you are safely on the other side.
Watching.
Families can do this too.
One person becomes:
The difficult child.
The unstable one.
The irresponsible one.
The failure.
That role allows everyone else to feel more functional by comparison.
But there is a cost to needing somebody else to carry failure.
Because eventually you will fail too.
You will trust somebody you should not have trusted.
Stay somewhere too long.
Misread a situation.
Build something that does not work.
Make a decision you later regret.
And if your sense of safety depends on always being the person who knew better, your own mistakes become almost impossible to tolerate.
Why Public Humiliation Creates Fear Of Failure
This may be the part of cringe culture that matters most.
Every time we watch someone being punished for trying, we absorb a message.
Visibility is dangerous.
Trying is dangerous.
Being earnest is dangerous.
Getting something wrong is dangerous.
So we become very sophisticated spectators.
We know what the celebrity should have done.
What the entrepreneur should have done.
What the singer should have released.
Why the relationship failed.
Why the creator should have waited.
Meanwhile, our own work remains unfinished.
The business stays in drafts.
The song never gets released.
The difficult conversation does not happen.
The application is never submitted.
The risk is never taken.
Because if every awkward beginning can be replayed forever, waiting until we are completely
ready starts to sound sensible.
But perfection is an excellent way to never begin.
Cringe Culture Can Teach Us To Prefer Commentary To Participation
There is safety in commentary.
The critic is not on stage.
The spectator cannot miss the note.
The person analysing someone else's relationship cannot be publicly rejected inside that
relationship.
The person discussing somebody else's business failure has not necessarily risked building one.
And there is nothing wrong with learning from other people's experiences.
The problem begins when observation becomes a substitute for participation.
When watching everyone else take risks allows us to avoid taking our own.
Eventually we become incredibly sophisticated about life without actually living very much of it.
There is a difference between:
Learning from what you see
and:
Using what you see to justify staying safe.
One moves you forward.
The other keeps you in the audience.
What Happens The Morning After Everyone Laughs?
This may be the most interesting part of Raygun's story.
Not the original performance.
The morning after.
The internet has already decided who you are.
People have laughed.
Judged.
Created memes.
Written opinions.
And then you wake up.
What now?
There is almost an unwritten social rule around humiliation.
Disappear.
Hide.
Apologise sufficiently.
Demonstrate that you understand how embarrassed you should be.
But something strange happens when someone refuses.
They keep living.
They work again.
Speak again.
Create again.
Go outside.
Laugh.
Wear something beautiful.
Take another risk.
The crowd may have decided:
We know who you are now.
And the person answers:
No. You know something that happened to me.
Those are not the same thing.
You Are More Than The Worst Decision You Made
Most people will never become global memes.
But almost everyone knows what it feels like to become trapped inside an old identity.
The difficult daughter.
The woman who chooses the wrong men.
The person whose business failed.
The one who got divorced.
The person who never fulfilled their potential.
Sometimes the event itself is no longer what keeps us stuck.
It is the identity we built around it.
We start believing the story everybody else remembers.
But you are allowed to make a different decision today.
You are allowed to stop playing the role everybody knows you for.
You are allowed to outgrow people's interpretation of you.
And you are allowed to keep living after being spectacularly wrong about something.
The Fear Of Being Seen Is Really The Fear Of Being Defined
Many people say they are afraid of failure.
But perhaps what they are really afraid of is what failure might mean socially.
What will people think?
Will they think I am foolish?
Will they think I am delusional?
Will I become the person everybody talks about?
Will I lose credibility?
The fear is not only:
What if this does not work?
It is:
What if this does not work and people decide that says something permanent
about me?
That is why self-trust matters.
Not because self-trust means believing every decision you make will be right.
It means knowing that one wrong decision does not have the authority to become your entire identity.
How To Stop Being Afraid Of What People Think
You cannot completely control how other people perceive you.
There will always be someone who misunderstands.
Someone who dislikes what you make.
Someone who believes you made the wrong choice.
Someone who thinks your risk was foolish.
Freedom does not come from finally managing every person's opinion.
It comes from becoming less willing to abandon your life to avoid their judgement.
That might mean:
Publishing before you feel completely ready.
Starting again after something fails.
Allowing an old version of you to remain in somebody else's memory.
Trying something without knowing whether you will be good at it.
Being seen learning.
Being seen changing your mind.
Being seen getting it wrong.
The goal is not humiliation.
The goal is becoming less controlled by the possibility of it.
A Question Worth Asking When You Become Obsessed With Someone Else's Downfall
The next time you find yourself unusually fascinated by somebody else's failure, ask:
What exactly am I reacting to?
Is there something useful to learn here?
Does this person's behaviour genuinely conflict with something I value?
Am I comparing myself with them?
Does their fall make something in my own life feel easier?
Do they represent something I secretly want?
And perhaps the deepest question:
Am I using their risk to justify my own safety?
Because someone else's humiliation can teach you to hide.
Or it can remind you of something much more important.
Human beings survive being wrong.
They survive embarrassment.
They survive relationships ending.
They survive failed businesses.
They survive public mistakes.
Life continues.
The Real Freedom Is Not Never Falling
Maybe freedom is not making sure nobody ever sees you fall.
Maybe it is knowing that even if you fall...
you do not have to build a home there.
You can learn.
Repair what needs repairing.
Take responsibility where necessary.
Change.
Begin again.
And refuse to turn one moment into your entire identity.
The internet loves freezing people inside moments.
Your life does not have to.
Perhaps that is the deepest lesson underneath all of these public downfalls:
A human being is always more than the moment we caught them in.
Including you.
If you recognise how fear of judgement, failure or other people's reactions has quietly shaped
your choices, my Shadow Archetype Quiz explores some of the patterns we hide, reject or
react to most strongly — and what those reactions can reveal about us.

Comments